Enforcement record

HSBC Bank Plc

Financial Conduct Authority · Fines

What the regulator published

Action detail

On 2 December 2011 the FSA imposed a financial penalty of £10,500,000 on HSBC Bank plc (HSBC) relating to investment advice and sales of investment products provided by one of its subsidiaries, NHFA Limited (NHFA), between 15 July 2005 and 20 July 2010 (the Relevant Period). During the Relevant Period, 2,485 customers were advised to invest in asset-backed investment products, typically investment bonds, which were used to fund long-term care costs for elderly customers. The sales were made by NHFA and resulted in a breach of Principle 9 (Customers: relationships of trust) of the FSA's Principles for Businesses and associated rules. HSBC agreed to settle at an early stage of the FSA's investigation. It therefore qualified for a 30% (stage 1) reduction in penalty, pursuant to the FSA's executive settlement procedures. Were it not for this discount, the FSA would have imposed a financial penalty of £15,000,000 on HSBC. The failings identified in respect of NHFA sales included the following: 1) In a number of cases reviewed the customer's life expectancy at the point of sale was less than the minimum recommended term of the investment (five years). That meant that it was likely the charges on the bond would reduce capital to such an extent that the product was unsuitable. 2) There was no consistent approach to assessing customers attitude to risk or use of a suitable risk profiling questionnaire. This deficiency in the sales process meant that advisers often recommended investment strategies to customers that were inconsistent with the customers tolerance for risk. 3) There was inadequate diversification of investments and savings plans. The majority of recommendations were for investment bonds with little or no consideration given to the use of other suitable forms of investments such as OEICs/unit trusts, ISAs, National Savings and fixed rate deposits. A review of customer files showed that, in the majority of cases, a different product should have been recommended or no product should have been recommended at all. 4) Advisers failed to consider the tax status of customers before making a recommendation. As a result customers may not have been aware of suitable alternative investments which were potentially more tax efficient for their individual circumstances. 5) Customers were given recommendations to invest a high proportion of funds into asset-backed investments with only a small amount of funds left readily available to them on deposit. This resulted in many cases in high levels of withdrawals from the invested assets being necessary despite this being foreseeable at the time of the recommendation. The combination of withdrawals and product charges led to faster reduction of capital than should have been the case if customers had received the right advice. 6) The suitability letters issued by NHFA advisers to customers were inadequate in that they: a) were not tailored to the circumstances of the individual customer; b) focussed unduly on the benefits of an investment without providing sufficient warnings about the possible disadvantages; and c) contained inaccurate or irrelevant information. As a consequence of the failings, NHFA customers were exposed to an unacceptable risk of mis-selling and a significant number of asset-backed investments were mis-sold. The FSA views these failings as particularly serious because: 1) NHFA was the leading supplier in the UK of independent financial advice on long-term care products to help pay for care costs, with a market share in recent years approaching 60%; 2) NHFA's customer base was particularly vulnerable given the customers age and in many cases they were reliant upon their investments to fund their care costs. They therefore had limited means or opportunity to make up any financial loss resulting from an unsuitable sale. This risked impacting on their ability to fund care arrangements; 3) the mis-conduct occurred over a period of approximately 5 years; 4) aignificant number of customers may have suffered financial detriment. During the Relevant Period 2,485 customers invested in asset-backed products. The total amount invested was approximately £285 million, meaning the average amount invested per customer was approximately £115,000. HSBC estimates that the amount of redress to be paid to affected will be approximately £29.3 million; and 5) HSBC is a major global financial services provider with a prominent position in the retail consumer market. The failings therefore merit the imposition of a substantial financial penalty. In deciding upon the appropriate level of penalty, the FSA has taken the following into account: 1) HSBC identified the serious failings at NHFA, provided a report to the FSA and implemented a comprehensive improvement programme at NHFA to address its failings. This involved making improvements to NHFA's sales processes and the training provided to its managers and advisers. As a result, a review by a third party of a sample of NHFA sales made after July 2010 demonstrated significant improvements; 2) HSBC has taken a proactive approach to reviewing all sales made by NHFA between April 2004 and July 2010 to determine where redress should be paid. Given the vulnerability of the customer base and the time elapsed, HSBC will not make contact with the customers or the advisers involved. Sales have been reviewed on the basis of the information available on the file only. Where it is unclear if the file was suitable, HSBC will assess the file as unsuitable and pay full redress; 3) HSBC implemented the customer redress programme, with a third party, before the referral to enforcement was made; and 4) HSBC agreed the facts of the investigation quickly and the FSA was able to rely on its review of NHFA sales and a review by a third party without further extensive investigation being necessary. HSBC closed NHFA to new business on 1 July 2011.

This reproduces the regulator’s published wording. It is not a summary and not an assessment.

Source verification

Record

Legal entityHSBC Bank Plc
RegulatorFinancial Conduct Authority
Action typeFines
FrameworkFSMA
Reference114216
Effective
Source last checkedyesterday
SourceOpen the official record

Always check the linked original before relying on a record. A source outage does not change the last verified status.

How to read this record

An enforcement record states that a regulator took a named action on a stated date. It does not describe the firm’s position today, and it does not extend to any related or successor entity.

Directory presence and claim status convey no endorsement and no adverse inference about any firm. Absence of a record is not evidence that a firm is unregulated.